Thursday, February 20, 2014

Dear 8th Graders

Dear 8th Graders,

Way back in the fall of 2005, you entered kindergarten and a little experiment was going on.
You had a student in your class with an extra chromosome, otherwise known as Down Syndrome.
No one came out and told you about this student and you just accepted him the way you accepted all of the other children in your class.

He couldn't run as fast as you could.
He couldn't write as well as you could.
He couldn't speak clearly.
And yet, he was part of you.

You figured it out.
You naturally, without any adult intervention, knew that this guy needed some support.  
You let him use a different kind of basket when you played two on two basketball.
You threw the ball a bit differently so that he could catch it more often.
You walked a little slower to be by his side.

You accepted him.

Did you know you had a choice?

Not really...because we tricked you.
We just put him in your kindergarten class --
where kindergarteners just want to have fun.


When Patrick was born, as soon as he was born, the doctor whisked him away, checked him all over and brought him back to us a few hours later with a new label:
 Down Syndrome.

The doctor closed the door.
He put a sign on the door telling others not to visit us.
He didn't even let Jack or Mary Kate come in to see their little brother.
He thought this label would take some getting used to.  
He thought we would be crying and scared.
He wanted us to have time.

He was coming from a good place...trying to be kind...but in truth, he was being cruel.

You know why??

He never went to school alongside someone who had this label.
He was afraid of it.
He didn't understand it.
He thought it was worth grieving.

Patrick did not get a celebration in those first hours of his birth.
No joy.
No laughing and photo-ops.
A whole lot of serious.

Can you imagine?

Probably the one person who is as joy-filled as could be and that was his welcome.
Maybe that's why he celebrates birthdays, all birthdays, in the biggest way possible now.

What was it like when you were born?

Oh, how your family celebrated!
How loved and awaited you were.


So here we are nine years after beginning the experiment.
1,520 days you've been together.
Only 100 left until graduation.

I can't thank you enough for your acceptance.
Your grace.
Your friendship and kindness...

you know why?

Because you weren't nice out of pity or because morally you thought you should or because you were trying to be nice or even because your parents told you to be nice.

You were accepting because you had the chance to get to know someone before you knew his label.

Best of all, Patrick had this chance.

That was our dearest hope for Patrick...
at St. James he could be Jack and Mary Kate's little brother.  
He didn't have to be "Patrick with Down Syndrome".

He got to just be Patrick.

If only you could know how profound that gift is.
Everywhere else, and I mean everywhere else, he is "Patrick with Down Syndrome".

Here, in this little school of 300, he is label-less.
It's grace in the

Did you know that Patrick will be the first person with Down Syndrome to graduate from a Catholic school in our entire diocese???
He's the only person I know that has Down Syndrome and is on student council, anywhere.

Do you know that because of your acceptance and the way your class has shown the school and the bigger world how to be as people that you are changing the world?

For the better.

Do you know that still to this day principals and priests at other schools say no when a family that has a child with Down Syndrome asks to go to their parish school??
That craziness still happens.

Because that principal or that priest didn't go to school alongside of people with disabilities.
They're scared and ignorant.
They don't realize just how normal it is.

Someday you might be a principal.
Or a teacher.
Or a banker.
Or a parent.

I know that your kindness and awareness will be reflected in those jobs.
I can't wait to see what you do with your level of justice and equality and care.
I'm so excited about our future.
Because of you.
(And your parents, of course.)

Let's make the last 100 days the best yet.
Now you know the experiment.
You can tell your side of the story.
Share what you know.
Share your experiences.

Share with the world what equality and social justice looks like and feels like...
wait, it just feels normal....
like how it's supposed to be.
Exactly, my friends.

Never tolerate segregation or separation.
You know the truth.

Together, we're better.


  1. As I read this with tears in my eyes, I say "Thank you God for your Grace which is everywhere!"
    Our Grace we received was in Patrick! How blessed are we! Amazing Beth....

    1. "Thank you God for your Grace which is everywhere." Exactly Shannon! Thank you for your sweet message and kindness. ~Beth

  2. Truly inspirational - God has a plan for all of us and thankfully Patrick was part of His plan for this 8th grade class and the St. James School community. We are truly blessed.

    1. Ed, Thanks so much for taking the time to comment...that's my favorite part of blogging -- the back and forth. I agree completely -- God has a plan. Grateful for your kindness and Colleen's as well. ~Beth

  3. Knowing Patrick and having the opportunity to be even a very small part of his extraordinary life has been a huge blessing for our family. I am so grateful for that wisdom that urged you to share your angel in this gracefully ordinary way. Thank you. You and Patrick have given us so much.

    1. Barbara, Thanks for taking the time to means a lot. We are so so grateful for Anthony and his friendship for these many years. What a joy he is and to see them both so big now is both amazing and very bittersweet. It goes fast! Grateful to have spent this time with wonderful people like you and your family. ~Beth

  4. today, I say we give this earth to the children.

  5. Dear Beth,

    My name is Ellie Zapata and I work at the C21 Center at Boston College. We are seeking permission to reprint your blog in our free magazine. Please email me at Thank you.

  6. As I write this I have tears in my eyes. The world NEEDS this powerful message so badly right now. I am blessed to teach at a Catholic school within the Archdiocese of Milwaukee that opens its doors and welcomes ALL children because isn't THAT what schools are for...educating children?!? I am so excited for the 2017-18 school year to begin. I teach 4K and will have the privilege of welcoming not one, but TWO little special children of God who happen to have Downs Syndrome. I am certain that it will be one of the most rewarding years of my career. We also have a Down Syndrome student graduating from 8th grade this year and another graduating next year. Your words are so true. Our students didn't need to be prepared to have these students in their classes. They have grown and learned together, side-by-side, and have learned to accept similarities as well as differences. God created us all as unique individuals. Together we ARE so much better:) God bless you and congratulations!!